Accès ouvert · CC BY

An experts’ opinion-based comparison and benefit cost analysis of post-mortem versus tuberculin skin test surveillance systems, Mpumalanga, South Africa

Article scientifique 2020 Sciences de la santé › Santé publique › Santé mondiale (OCDE 3.3) Anglais

Résumé

Abstract BackgroundTuberculosis (TB) is a global health concern caused mostly by Mycobacterium bovis (M. bovis) and Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tuberculosis) in animals and humans respectively. As part of TB control strategies, most governments instituted test and slaughter policies for bovine TB (bTB) eradication with varied level of success.MethodsUsing the SurvCost® (http://www.cdc.gov/idsr/survcost.htm), we evaluated the postmortem surveillance (PMS) system as an alternative to the tuberculin skin test (TST). Experts’opinions survey was used to collect information on the perceived level of acceptability of PMS and TST, successes and challenges of both surveillance systems, economic and budget data. Benefit cost analysis of both systems were evaluated and the comparative economic benefit of PMS over TST was determined.ResultsTST implementation was challenging due to poor logistics, procurement challenge, poor feedback, inconsistency in testing and poor return rate for retesting. Experts agreed that PMS was cheaper but almost impracticable due to late detection and probable poor compliance rate but farmers were more open to PMS than TST. Personnel cost remains the largest part of the surveillance cost (47.8% of total costs). TST and PMS systems can be up to 4.40 and 5.96 times more beneficial that not tackling bTB respectively and PMS is 1.35 more cost beneficial that TST.ConclusionWhile TST is empirical, compliance by farmers was poor due to the associated inconveniences. In the alternative, PMS was convenient for farmers but experts believed that adherence will be poor unless increased manpower is available. We advocated for a blended approach between the two systems. Improved field surveillance and detailed economic data should benefit future economic assessment.Trial registrationNot applicable.

Citer ce document

Marange, R., Fasina, F. O., Reininghaus, B., & Morar-Leather, D. (2020). An experts’ opinion-based comparison and benefit cost analysis of post-mortem versus tuberculin skin test surveillance systems, Mpumalanga, South Africa. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-34964/v1

Exporter : BibTeX · RIS (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote)

Accès au document

Texte intégral archivé sur SPHAERO, en accès ouvert : lisible gratuitement en ligne après connexion. Le document reste aussi disponible à sa source. Se connecter

Voir l'article sur le site de la revue

Licence et provenance

Licence : CC BY

Notice moissonnée depuis OpenAlex le 04/09/2026. Le document reste hébergé par sa source.
Voir le document à la source →

Statistiques

Consultations (hors robots) : 15

Téléchargements (hors robots) : 0

Méthode de comptage