Accès ouvert · CC BY

How Could the Pension Funds Adjudicator Get it so Wrong A Critique of Smith v Eskom Pension and Provident Fund

Article scientifique 2017 Sciences juridiques et politiques Anglais

Résumé

In this case note the judgment in the Smith case is criticized for being inconsistent with the landmark ruling in Volks. It is argued that the Adjudicator ought to have remanded the matter in Smith to the Board and ought to have ordered it to re-examine its discretion with a focus on a set of factors. Some of the negative effects of Smith on the pension funds industry are also outlined. While the authors express their understanding that the Adjudicator's decision in Smith was made with the rights of women in mind, they believe that her reasoning was wrong. She may have arrived at the same decision on different reasoning. In order to prevent the negative effects of Smith on the pension funds industry, it is recommended that the Adjudicator, when given an opportunity, should overrule the precedent set in Smith. Failure to do so would create the risk of the inconsistent application of the term "spouse" under South African law, or at the very least in relation to acts of Parliament administered by the National Treasury, which may potentially violate the equality provisions of the Constitution.

Citer ce document

Dyani-Mhango, N., & Mhango, M. (2017). How Could the Pension Funds Adjudicator Get it so Wrong A Critique of Smith v Eskom Pension and Provident Fund. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal/Potchefstroomse Elektroniese Regsblad. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2010/v13i2a2646

Exporter : BibTeX · RIS (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote)

Accès au document

Texte intégral archivé sur SPHAERO, en accès ouvert : lisible gratuitement en ligne après connexion. Le document reste aussi disponible à sa source. Se connecter

Voir l'article sur le site de la revue

Licence et provenance

Licence : CC BY

Notice moissonnée depuis OpenAlex le 27/08/2026. Le document reste hébergé par sa source.
Voir le document à la source →

Statistiques

Consultations (hors robots) : 6

Téléchargements (hors robots) : 0

Méthode de comptage