Alienation of Restituted Land in South Africa: A Systematic Review of Legal Safeguards and CPA Governance
Résumé
The alienation of restituted land is a recurrent tension within South Africa’s land reform program, sitting at the intersection of constitutional imperatives, statutory safeguards, and practical governance challenges. This article asks whether existing legal safeguards adequately prevent the alienation of restituted land, which undermines restitution’s objectives. We argue that while section 12 of the Communal Property Associations Act 28 of 1996 requires ministerial consent and majority support for any transaction involving CPA-held land, including leases and sales, the persistence of non-compliance and governance failures suggests a gap between legal design and implementation. This article employs a systematic literature review and document analysis of statutes, policies, and recent jurisprudence (2015–2025) to evaluate whether existing safeguards adequately prevent alienation that undermines the objectives of restitution. In this study, 300 sources were screened; only 66 were reviewed because they provided sufficient information on safeguards and CPAs in South Africa. Results show that although South Africa’s statutory framework provides formal safeguards against the alienation of restituted land, systemic governance failures, elite capture within Community Property Associations, and weak state oversight routinely undermine these protections. This manifests in widespread de facto alienation through unauthorised leasing, commercial partnerships, and decision-making that excludes beneficiary communities. It was further revealed that while legal safeguards are theoretically sufficient to support the functionality of CPAs, alienation persists due to institutional misalignment. We argue that the failure of CPAs to sustain the communities they serve largely stems from policy mismatch vis-à-vis the realities these institutions face. Essentially, comparative perspectives from Kenya, Namibia, and Zimbabwe highlight similar safeguards while underscoring the importance of robust enforcement mechanisms. This is crucial for closing the gap between theoretical safeguards and practical challenges arising from alienation of CPAs. Therefore, policy reform should target not only institutional functionality but also the strengthening of protection against alienation.
Citer ce document
Exporter : BibTeX · RIS (Zotero, Mendeley, EndNote)
Accès au document
Texte intégral archivé sur SPHAERO, en accès ouvert : lisible gratuitement en ligne après connexion. Le document reste aussi disponible à sa source. Se connecter
Voir l'article sur le site de la revueLicence et provenance
Licence : CC BY
Notice moissonnée depuis OpenAlex le 26/10/2026. Le document reste hébergé par sa source.
Voir le document à la source →